Welfare Drug Testing Should Not Be Allowed - 1416 Words

With 35.4% of Americans on welfare, and the U.S spending over 131 billion on welfare annually, not including food stamps. People have been looking for a way to cut the costs of welfare for many years. And then Welfare drug testing was proposed. At initial thought it seemed like a grand idea and a great way to cut costs and to eliminate all the drug users in the system, and because of that welfare drug testing has been put into action in 13 states. But, welfare drug testing is completely ineffective. Welfare drug testing should not be allowed because it violates the rights of the welfare recipients, it is stereotyping and discriminating against people on welfare, and it is expensive and ineffective . For all these reasons mandatory†¦show more content†¦This small bit of information should be enough for the government to stop the because it breaks one of the key laws this nation was built on, yet they still have it is action. Supporters of Welfare drug testing might say that it is completely unfair and unjust that often before people can start working they have to submit a drug test, but people on welfare don’t have to to receive government handouts, but it a completely different situation because all of the businesses that require employees to take a drug test are privately owned. Drug test are needed to insure that employees can be relied on to do their job such as police and army. Welfare is different because it is managed by the government which is not allowed to do drug tests because of the fourth amendment. Finally, welfare recipients should have the right to not tell the government everything about them when they apply for government handouts. As Judge Stanley Marcus, said that Citizens do not abandon all hope of privacy by applying for government assistance.† (Amy Sherman) Everybody deserves the right to privacy, even people applying for welfare as the quote says they have the right to have some privacy and to not be forced to take drug tests and to get bombarded by random checking by the government. Another reason that welfare drug testing should be banned is because it is based off stereotypes and discrimination. Welfare drug testing is stereotyping because many of the people who support